Blind test · voice-v1 · EN-US · updated October 30, 2026

PlayHT is gone: what to use instead, tested blind

No link on this page earns us money. If we join an affiliate program, we will say so here and next to each link; it will never change the ranking. Disclosure

Illustration: a blindfolded listener wearing headphones between two sound waves

Short answer

PlayHT no longer works. play.ht and play.ai stopped resolving (we checked on October 30, 2026), and the service closed on December 31, 2025 according to its competitors' migration notes. In our blind test of 8 companies reading the same 30-second ad, the best replacement was ElevenLabs Eleven v4, which never lost a head-to-head; Cartesia Sonic 3.6 came second.

On a budget: ElevenLabs' Eleven v4 Turbo (about $0.04 a minute at list price) scored level with Eleven v4, and Cartesia Sonic 3.6 costs about $0.05.

What happened to PlayHT

Below: the replacements, ranked by our blind listening test. See also ElevenLabs alternatives and the full ranking of every voice.

PlayHT replacements, ranked blind

Company level: every blind head-to-head on the 30-second ad, both listeners and both genders together. "Clear second" means clearly ahead of most companies below it. Below that, the order is too close to call.

#Company (best voice)Won–lost–too closeResultPer minuteListen
1 ElevenLabs (Eleven v4 · Jade) 29–1–7 Picked best $0.08 / $0.04
AI-generated voice: ElevenLabs / Eleven v4 / Jade
2 Cartesia (Sonic 3.6 · Daniel) 15–7–6 Clear second $0.05
AI-generated voice: Cartesia / Sonic 3.6 / Daniel (re-recorded on a paid plan)
3 Fish Audio (Drama 3 · Hannah) 3–6–4 $0.05 / $0.015 Sample not published yet (license check)
4 Google Gemini (Gemini 3.8 Flash-Lite TTS · Charon) 4–17–9 $0.009 / $0.014
AI-generated voice: Google Gemini / Gemini 3.8 Flash-Lite TTS / Charon
5 MiniMax (Speech 2.8 HD · Upbeat Woman) 4–8–0 $0.10 Sample not published yet (license check)
6 Speechify (Simba 3.5 · Chase) 2–4–0 $0.02
AI-generated voice: Speechify / Simba 3.5 / Chase
7 OpenAI (gpt-realtime-2.1-mini · Marin) 2–7–3 $0.024
AI-generated voice: OpenAI / gpt-realtime-2.1-mini / Marin
8 Murf (Falcon 2.1 · Natalie) 1–10–1 $0.01 / $0.03 Sample not published yet (license check)

Each sample is the company's best-placed voice. Cartesia's samples were re-recorded on its paid plan after the test, with the same voice and settings. Fish Audio, MiniMax and Murf samples are not published because the license for our test clips is unclear.

What the replacements cost per minute

At API list prices, one minute of speech costs from about $0.009 (Google Gemini 3.8 Flash-Lite TTS) to $0.10 (MiniMax Speech 2.8 HD). Our winner, ElevenLabs Eleven v4, is about $0.08; v4 Turbo about $0.04.

One minute is about 1,000 characters; our clips used 800 to 1,000. Prices from each company's own pricing page; we keep a dated copy of every page we quote.

EngineList pricePer minuteChecked
ElevenLabs Eleven v4 (our winner) $0.08 / 1,000 chars $0.08
ElevenLabs Eleven v4 Turbo $0.04 / 1,000 chars $0.04
Cartesia Sonic 3.6 Pro $5/mo for 100K credits $0.05
OpenAI gpt-realtime-2.1-mini per audio token $0.024
Speechify Simba 3.5 $0.02 / 1,000 chars $0.02
Fish Audio Drama 3 / s2.1-pro $0.05 / 1,000 chars / $0.015 / 1,000 chars $0.05 / $0.015
Gemini 3.8 Flash / Flash-Lite TTS per audio token $0.014 / $0.009
Murf Falcon 2.1 / Gen2 $0.01 / 1,000 chars / $0.03 / 1,000 chars $0.01 / $0.03
MiniMax Speech 2.8 HD $0.10 / 1,000 chars $0.10

Can you use it commercially?

ToolCommercial useCheapest option for itChecked
ElevenLabsPaid plans only; the free plan is non-commercialStarter, $6/month
CartesiaPaid plans only: Pro and up include a commercial license (ads included, by our reading of the terms); the free plan is non-commercialPro, $5/month
Fish AudioPaid plans; their own library voices are unclear (we asked)Paid API
Google GeminiYes, Google claims no ownership of the audioPay as you go (API)
MiniMaxYes on their own accounts (output is yours)Pay as you go (API)
SpeechifyYes, from the free API plan; disclose that the voice is AIFree API plan
OpenAIYes, you own the output; tell listeners the voice is AIPay as you go (API)
MurfPaid plans; the free Studio plan has no commercial rightsStudio from $19/month (annual)

Questions people ask

Does Play HT still exist?

No. play.ht no longer resolves (checked October 30, 2026), and PlayHT closed on December 31, 2025 after Meta took over its team in July 2025, according to its competitors' migration notes.

Is PlayAI shutting down?

It already has. PlayAI was the company behind PlayHT; its products closed on December 31, 2025, and play.ai no longer resolves either (checked October 30, 2026).

How much does PlayHT cost?

Nothing, because it can no longer be bought. For comparison, our blind test's winner, ElevenLabs Eleven v4, costs about $0.08 a minute at API list price, and Cartesia Sonic 3.6 about $0.05.

What happened to my PlayHT voice clones?

According to Inworld AI's migration guide, saved audio and voice clones were deleted when PlayHT closed. We could not check this ourselves. If you still have your original recordings, you can clone the voice again with another service.

What is the best PlayHT alternative for ads?

In our blind test of 8 companies on a 30-second ad, ElevenLabs Eleven v4 was picked best and never lost a head-to-head (20 wins, 0 losses, 13 too close). Cartesia Sonic 3.6 came second.

How we tested

Same script for every tool, the vendor's newest model on the test day, voices chosen by a fixed rule, two takes per voice. Clips leveled to the same loudness, names hidden, sides shuffled per listener: two voices at a time, the listener picks the better one, until one is left. Every clip was transcribed by speech-to-text, and flagged spots were re-checked with 4 models.

The ad script every voice read:

Still wrapping gifts at midnight? Meet Novalo, the gift box that lights up the moment it opens. One tap, and your present feels like a little show. Order today for just fifty-nine ninety-five, and get free shipping across the US. Novalo. Make every gift a moment.

Read the test rules

Engines
12, from 8 companies
Head-to-heads
92 (ranked script: 30-second ad)
Voices
24 (12 per gender)
Scripts
ad, explainer, UGC, pronunciation, warm, phone menu
Listening
Blind, 2 listeners
Loudness
All at −16 LUFS
Run
Oct 26–30, 2026
Tested by
Nick

Independent. Rankings come from the test, never from commissions, and vendors don't see results before we publish. Disclosure

Changelog